Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 4) (Done, moved to part 5)

Level 7 CPU 1169 RoyMaster4

I'll give Sim City the OK. Sounds good to me.

Guys, we need more votes! Spyro, Starfy, etc.... don't they deserve stages?

633 Mp3_Toaster

Update

1. Since Sim City got a lot of support quickly. It's now on the main roster!

2. All suggestions for the Main stages has been accepted. When it comes to the Wario series. Max amount of stages will probably be 4. Maybe for Yoshi and F-Zero too. So if both Wario stages get enough support. They will be in without competitions. If you think 4 stages for Wario and Yoshi is too much. Please state your objections. The number of stages for the smash series are still undecided. But it's likely they can have more than 4.

Stage Confirmed:
Sim City

Following series that accepts more stages:
Smash Series
Yoshi
Wario
F-Zero

Main Stages

Spoiler:

Misc Stages

Spoiler:

Suggested Replacements

Spoiler:

Removal Listing

Spoiler:

8837

If the Traverse Town supporters all switch to Castle Oblivion, KH can have a stage.

Anyways, I'll support Wuhu Island, Ninja Castle and Battleground

Level 8 CPU 1703

I haven't voted for Swapnote? I'm voting for Swapnote and Wuhu Island.

Level 7 CPU 1169 RoyMaster4

I believe 4 stages is too much for Wario or Yoshi, 3 max (Though we all voted 2 almost unanimously). Undecided on Tower Climb, as a Yoshi's Story stage would be nice but I fail to see the significance or uniqueness of what DMX proposed. Also don't like either Wario rep - if we're going to have another Wario stage, maybe Wario World would be the best choice to rep.

I'll support DMX's Space Colony now that I've seen the layout and gimmick. Pretty good.

8837

3 Super Metroid stages? Seriously? If you want Space Colony, at least replace an existing Super Metroid stage and not a Prime stage.

Level 8 CPU 1703

Correction of the Day: Brinstar Depths is from the original Metroid.

3883

I think what he meant was 3 stages form the old-school Metroid games, which were vastly different than the Prime games and Other M.

8837

I'm looking at this:

Quote :: 27. Planet Zebes [64] (Super Metroid)
28. Brinstar Depths (Super Metroid)
29. Phazon Mines (Metroid Prime)
30. Main Sector (Metroid: Other M)
31. Chozo Ruins (Metroid Prime)

Take out Phazon Mines for Space Colony and you have:

Quote :: 27. Planet Zebes [64] (Super Metroid)
28. Brinstar Depths (Super Metroid)
29. Space Colony (Super Metroid)
30. Main Sector (Metroid: Other M)
31. Chozo Ruins (Metroid Prime)

Edit
I see. OP is incorrect, Brinstar Depths comes from Metroid.

I'd still prefer to keep the Prime stages. If we replace Phazon Mines, it should be from a Prime 2 or Prime 3 location.

Level 8 CPU 1703

Brinstar Depths is not from Super Metroid.
Besides, Planet Zebes (to me) counts as a Super Smash Bros. stage rather than a Super Metroid stage.

8837

Dr.MarioX wrote:: Brinstar Depths is not from Super Metroid.
Besides, Planet Zebes (to me) counts as a Super Smash Bros. stage rather than a Super Metroid stage.

That's like saying Hyrule Castle isn't an OoT stage. Doesn't matter if it appeared in Smash, the location is not from Smash.

Level 7 CPU 1169 RoyMaster4

You know, Planet Zebes is Brinstar and is thus from the original Metroid.... so technically we have 0 Super Metroid stages until this.

As far as Hyrule Castle, I always considered it a Link to the Past stage, as its the only game where you actually fight inside Hyrule Castle (Barring Twilight Princess, but the stage is from before). It took the looks of the OoT version, but it's still a LttP stage.

8837

RoyMaster4 wrote:: You know, Planet Zebes is Brinstar and is thus from the original Metroid.... so technically we have 0 Super Metroid stages until this.

As far as Hyrule Castle, I always considered it a Link to the Past stage, as its the only game where you actually fight inside Hyrule Castle (Barring Twilight Princess, but the stage is from before). It took the looks of the OoT version, but it's still a LttP stage.

That's beside the point. Either way I wouldn't call it a Smash series stage.

And in this case, I'd remove Zebes or Bristar Depths. Why do we need 2 stages of the same location from the same game?

Level 7 CPU 1169 RoyMaster4

I propose we replace Phazon with Space Colony, and then replace Brinstar Depths for something from Fusion (I'd like Sector 5 ARC). That way, we have Metroid, Super Metroid, Fusion, Prime, and Other M all represented. Everything covered.

... *Waits for arguing*

8837

^ This.

Level 6 CPU 908

Tower Climb
Great Maze

3883

RoyMaster4 wrote:: I propose we replace Phazon with Space Colony, and then replace Brinstar Depths for something from Fusion (I'd like Sector 5 ARC). That way, we have Metroid, Super Metroid, Fusion, Prime, and Other M all represented. Everything covered.

... *Waits for arguing*

I agree.

633 Mp3_Toaster

Update

1. Only one objected to having 4 stages as max for Wario and Yoshi. I will bring up a side poll to decide the number of stages for both of the series, but only if objections from more people has been brought up. Right now there is not enough. If the side poll does happen. The votes for both Wario stages and the Yoshi stage will be put on-hold.

2. Swapnote only needs 1 more vote before it gets confirmed... Actually I just vote on it, just to be generous. So confirmed!

Stage Confirmed:
Swapnote (3DS)

Following series that accepts more stages:
Smash Series
Yoshi
Wario
F-Zero

Main Stages

Spoiler:

Misc Stages

Spoiler:

Suggested Replacements

Spoiler:

Removal Listing

Spoiler:

Level 8 CPU 1703

RoyMaster4 wrote:: I propose we replace Phazon with Space Colony, and then replace Brinstar Depths for something from Fusion (I'd like Sector 5 ARC). That way, we have Metroid, Super Metroid, Fusion, Prime, and Other M all represented. Everything covered.

... *Waits for arguing*

This. I'll be playing Fusion soon.

Level 7 CPU 1169 RoyMaster4

I vote we either replace Poke Floats 2 for a Gen VI stage or just add one. We can't just ignore a whole generation...

Guest

Voting to replace Poke Floars 2 for a Gen VI stage.

EDIT: Voting for Great Maze.

1763 Ariand54321

Voting for the Advance Wars Stage.

Also looks like we're gonna need a gen 6 stage now, huh? Troll

3883

I'll support Great Maze. I also support removal of Pokefloats 2 for a Gen VI stage.

8837

Remove Phazon for Space Colony, and remove Poke Floats 2 for something Gen VI.

Level 6 CPU 908

Replace Poke Floats 2 for Gen VI stage

Level 5 CPU 468

I vote Poke Floats 2 get remplace for Pokemon X-Y ( Generation VI ) Stage

Guest

Sense there seems to be NO WAY to change people's minds to have no "Unknown Generation VI Stage" I propose we simply ADD a stage for Generation VI, and Poke Floats 2 stays.

Level 5 CPU 468

Im ok with that .

Level 4 CPU 185

RoyMaster4 wrote:: I propose we replace Phazon with Space Colony, and then replace Brinstar Depths for something from Fusion (I'd like Sector 5 ARC). That way, we have Metroid, Super Metroid, Fusion, Prime, and Other M all represented. Everything covered.

... *Waits for arguing*

Great idea Clap

NeßeNeßeN wrote:: Sense there seems to be NO WAY to change people's minds to have no "Unknown Generation VI Stage" I propose we simply ADD a stage for Generation VI, and Poke Floats 2 stays.

This. Poké Floats 2 could have benefits too - more pokémon from Gen VI as platforms. But let's not rush it, the games aren't even out yet and they won't be for some time. I'm sure some worthy places will appear, but not now.

8837

But then it's even with Mario, and Mario definitely needs to be the sole series in it's stage rep bracket.

» Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 3)
» Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 2)
» Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 1)
» Prince Sabure (Kaeru No Tame Ni Kane Wa Naru) Discussion: Part Human, Part Frog, Part Snake, All A Hero!
» Super Smash Bros. Crusade Tiers Part 2 (High Tiers) Discussion!