Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 4) (Done, moved to part 5)

RoyMaster4 wrote:

Why Rogueport? Sure it's the hub and all, but couldn't we have something more fun like Shy Guy's Toy Box or the Woah Zone?

(Also, sure, count me for Forest Maze as well... I guess why not)

Rogueport is better than all of those

Rogueport please.

Remove Forest Maze.

@SP, are you also voting for Forest Maze removal?

but smrpg was best rpg


my feels

Heavy Ridley wrote:

but smrpg was best rpg


my feels

BAHAHAHAHAHA

Oh sir, you made me laugh. I thank you.

For the Mario RPG I also Like Mario & Luigi on GBA And NDS but Paper Mario rock too much i vote for Forest Maze removal for a Paper Mario Stage Or a Mario & Luigi Stage .

I don't think a Mario & Luigi stage would really represent the Mario RPG series. I already casted my vote.

Rogueport > Stardust Fields > Forest Maze

I vote Rougeport.

Dr.MarioX wrote:

Rogueport > Stardust Fields > Forest Maze

I vote Rougeport.

We aren't there yet. We're still choosing what to replace.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Update on Set Numbered Poll
As of 12/8/12 at 3:38PM EST

7 votes for 120 stages

1 votes for 125 stages


------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Update on Stage Removal Poll
As of 12/8/12 at 3:38PM EST

3 votes for Satisfactory on Roster

17 votes for Removals on Roster

Removal Listings:

Spoiler:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Club Sugar, Luigi's Mansion, and Pokemon Colosseum removal votes aren't for me, are they?

I just said LM and PC should be placeholder names.

Dr.MarioX wrote:

The Club Sugar, Luigi's Mansion, and Pokemon Colosseum removal votes aren't for me, are they?

I just said LM and PC should be placeholder names.

Suggesting them as placeholders is no different from getting rid of them if people support a different stage to take it's place. But yea, I counted them as your vote. I can remove them if you like.

Remove them. I see the logic in Club Sugar now and as far as I'm concerned, Luigi's Mansion and Pokemon Colosseum are placeholder names.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Update on Set Numbered Poll
As of 12/9/12 at 6:53PM EST

7 votes for 120 stages

1 votes for 125 stages


------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Update on Stage Removal Poll
As of 12/9/12 at 6:53PM EST

3 votes for Satisfactory on Roster

17 votes for Removals on Roster

Removal Listings:

Spoiler:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

We'll eventually vote on what Arcade stages we're having, correct?

Whenever this topic dies out, then we will move on to suggesting misc. series stage. Can be anything from Arcade series to something more relevant.

anyone else want to add or change votes at this point?

Over half the people haven't voted on the number of stages...

Why is 20 the minimum number for removal? It seems like 90% of the active users want the stages out.

BluePsychic wrote:

Why is 20 the minimum number for removal? It seems like 90% of the active users want the stages out.

Actually its 11. lol

Oh, sorry.

BTW guys, though he hasn't posted it yet, Felipe wants to propose replacing Opera House with Floating Continent. What you guys think about that?

If the Atma/Ultima Weapon gets in as a hazard (just look at what it can do) and the stage itself has a good layout, then Opera House gets my removal vote
(I knew there was another reason behind that "The Fierce Battle" remix...)

Tbh never heard of Floating Continent (Or Opera House, though I was the one who suggested it... only because it came up in SSF2 discussions long ago, but nevermind that).

I support Opera House mainly because it sets the stage for Kefka.

I'd be fine with either, though i think Opera House wins for being possibly the most memorable scene in FF history, contending only with the death of Aeris.

I'll give this poll till the end of the day before I close it if it still remains to be inactive.

Felipe, would you still want to present your ideas of Floating Continent?

I suggest removing Opera House for the Floating continent.

Why?

Because opera house is a really bad place to use as a playable stage. in change, the floating continent is a more representative stage for FF 6 and it also gives more freedom for an "smash" layout

I came out with a mockup for it:



The big islands are the main platforms, the main hazard of this stage is Omega, the boss, that would appear randomly (a la Spear Pillar)

I even made a remix for the stage

Voting for Opera House in favor of Floating Continent

Mr. Mistress wrote:

Voting for Opera House in favor of Floating Continent

Do you mind any reasoning please?

I fail to see any potential on it, layout wise, the 2 available options is a flat walkoff stage or an imitation of the transformation 2 of castle siegue, aside from that, the only feasible >Hazards are ulros and the legendary dragon, and this both options pale in comparison to Omega.