Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 3)

Mrs. Master wrote:

No. I'm fine with the roster as it is.

^

TehKrazeMang~ wrote:

Mrs. Master wrote:

No. I'm fine with the roster as it is.

Also, can we at least remove Mute City until it gets revamped?

There's no point in removing something until it gets revamped. A feces of stages and characters will be revamped, but they aren't removed.

But Mute City as it stands is nothing but Battlefield with Cars rolling by frequently. We would lose pretty much nothing if it gets temporarily removed until it gets a proper design.

Yes.
Remove Chozo Ruins.

BOT wrote:

Yes.
Remove Chozo Ruins.

Again, dev voted stages cant be removed plus its already coded in

SmashKing201 wrote:

BOT wrote:

Yes.
Remove Chozo Ruins.

Again, dev voted stages cant be removed plus its already coded in

Oh shi- I forgot about that.

I'd say Good Egg Galaxy in favor of something else SMG related, but we can't... so...

I'm fine with everything as-is.

Actually, on second thought, could I see the stage layout for Forest Maze?

TehKrazeMang~ wrote:

Actually, on second thought, could I see the stage layout for Forest Maze?

In Felipe's deciption, it was a flat walk-off with a single platform on the left side and wrap-around gimmick

no

Yes
---------
pokefloats 2
Tal Tal Heights

I'm pretty sure that a Dev pick could get that Super Mario World stage in the game, so I'm not too worried about removing anything there yet.

One of those two other Donkey Kong stages needs to go for Minecart Madness.

I'm against having a second SNES Yoshi. I'd replace Baby Bowser's Bedroom with a Yoshi's Story stage.

I really think that other Zelda stage that only the devs have seen should be in. It's a perfect Zelda 1 stage. I'd say get rid of either Ocarina Medley or Palace of Winds.

Other M's Main Sector should be something else. I would say the Biosphere so we could have a stage that changes environment like it does in the game.

I'm pretty sure Zoness will be getting in by Dev pick...

I'm not the happiest with Pokemon stages. I think the Mirage Tower should be replaced with R/S/E's Route 119 (it may seem random, but it would really work). Pokemon Colosseum is too bland. It needs to be an actual location from the game or XD. As someone who has played both of those games since release, I think either Citadark Isle or Phenac City would be best.

Casino Palace is honestly probably not the best GX choice. Replace it with Aeropolis and we'd be better off.

That's what I think so far.

I say no.

Yes

Forest Maze in favor for Paper Mario stage. Geno is not worthy of a stage, none the less a roster spot that cant be changed.

Palace of Winds in favor for Tingle's Rupeeland. The only spin off in general without a stage

Airship Armada in favor for Bowser's Castle or Lava Land from SM64

Well considering the roster was determined in the most fair way it could have been, voting no change. Obviously noone will 100% agree with the current roster, that was the point of a series of popularity votes. Any stage currently on the roster that gets some removal votes will have a much higher number of users who actually support it, that's how it got on the list in the first place

No, I'm perfectly fine with what we have now. (Except maybe Victory Road)

No.

No

Update on Stage Removal Poll
As of 7/27/12 @ 12:34AM EST

Alright, we currently got the Nintendo series out the way for the time being. Before we jump into 3rd party stages, we will have a Removal Stage Poll.

The Removal Stage Poll is a poll where we will vote on Possibly replacing any stages from a series we have discussed at this point. So far, we have only discussed the Nintendo series.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here is the catch though. The following stages CANNOT be removed.

1. Stages already in-game & playable.
2. Stages that entered the roster by Dev Vote
3. Stages that are coded, but not yet publically in-game

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We will start this poll off with a simple "YES" or "NO".

Vote "YES" to remove stages & list which ones. Vote "NO" if your pleased with the results of the Stage Roster at this point.

If a stage/s have enough "YES" votes to be cut (at least 11 or more votes), it will be in danger of getting cut. A poll to will eventually take place afterwards for a replacement if necessary.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Total of 15 have voted

5 votes for "YES" (Remove & Replace)

10 votes for "NO" (Currently Satisfied)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Listed Candidates in danger of being cut.
NOTE: Stage names highlighted in RED means they are going to be cut as of this update.

(Open Spoilers To See Votes)

Spoiler:

SmashKing201 wrote:

Forest Maze in favor for Paper Mario stage. Geno is not worthy of a stage, none the less a roster spot that cant be changed.

Wanted to make a quick small response here.

The Forest Maze doesn't represent Geno alone, it represents the entire Mario RPG franchise. Since SMRPG was the first one and is still very memorable, it just ended up being the stage. The reason why it is the Forest Maze instead of any other location in SMRPG is because of it's popularity due to it's infamous maze. Nothing more, nothing less.

I hope.

Screw the rules, I vote to remove Final Destination and Battlefield.

How long do we plan on letting this poll run? Most people seem to only want one stage they don't like out or none at all, and the one stage seems to be different from person to person.


Though why not, I'll toss my vote in for Forest Maze. Rogueport, Excess Express, Underwhere/Overthere, Woah Zone, Dry Dry Ruins, and Shy Guy's Toy Box would be much more interesting choices than another forest level. Though I don't know if I could decide which one...

I'd like to change to yes.

Forest Maze (Replaced by a Paper Mario stage)
Main Sector (Replaced by any alternate Other M stage)

Yes

Airship Armada(To be replaced by Bowser's Castle), Forest Maze(To be Replaced by Star Road), Phazon Mines(to be replaced by Phaaze) (Posibally Add another Stage), Burned Tower(IDK), Foggy Fumes(Replaced By DK Arcade Stage)



For Later
Third Party
4 or 5 For Sonic
2 or 3 For Metal Gear
2 or 3 For MegaMan
2 for Castlevania
1 for Minecraft

Update on Stage Removal Poll
As of 7/28/12 @ 2:48AM EST

Alright, we currently got the Nintendo series out the way for the time being. Before we jump into 3rd party stages, we will have a Removal Stage Poll.

The Removal Stage Poll is a poll where we will vote on Possibly replacing any stages from a series we have discussed at this point. So far, we have only discussed the Nintendo series.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here is the catch though. The following stages CANNOT be removed.

1. Stages already in-game & playable.
2. Stages that entered the roster by Dev Vote
3. Stages that are coded, but not yet publically in-game

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We will start this poll off with a simple "YES" or "NO".

Vote "YES" to remove stages & list which ones. Vote "NO" if your pleased with the results of the Stage Roster at this point.

If a stage/s have enough "YES" votes to be cut (at least 11 or more votes), it will be in danger of getting cut. A poll to will eventually take place afterwards for a replacement if necessary.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Total of 16 have voted

8 votes for "YES" (Remove & Replace)

8 votes for "NO" (Currently Satisfied)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Listed Candidates in danger of being cut.
NOTE: Stage names highlighted in RED means they are going to be cut as of this update. Dont forget, a stage will need 11 or more votes to be cut.

(Open Spoilers To See Votes)

Spoiler:

Anyone wants to add or change votes?

Add my vote to Airship Armada

Does my vote count as a no?

Because I meant it to be one.

Tal Tal Heights

AEM wrote:

Does my vote count as a no?

Because I meant it to be one.

I counted it as a NO Removal

Anyone else want to add or change votes?

I vote YES, with Club sugar (replaced with SS Tea Cup) and Phazon Mines (replaced with Agon Wastes) We don't need two stages from Prime 1, even though it is my favorite game.