Crusade Stage Roster Discussion (Part 2)

If Onett comes back it should be redisned to be Nintens Home Town, the Melee onett isn't even politically correct in how its set up, it needs a redisngn.

Yeti Dk wrote:

If Onett comes back it should be redisned to be Nintens Home Town, the Melee onett isn't even politically correct in how its set up, it needs a redisngn.

Yeah, don't want to offend the Mother 2 fans

Even me being BluePsychic doesn't care about the towns layout. I don't want to see Onett back in the game though, and while I don't mind the towns layout in the background, I don't like the actual stage design.

Esper wrote:

Yeti Dk wrote:

If Onett comes back it should be redisned to be Nintens Home Town, the Melee onett isn't even politically correct in how its set up, it needs a redisngn.

Yeah, don't want to offend the Mother 2 fans

It's called EarthBound. You offend me sir.
Also, 3 stages. And to be honest, Ninten's home town of Podunk isn't a bad idea.

Yeti Dk wrote:

If Onett comes back it should be redisned to be Nintens Home Town, the Melee onett isn't even politically correct in how its set up, it needs a redisngn.

Ninten never lived in Onett. He lived in Podunk, as Gallade stated.

Bloody Gallade wrote:

Esper wrote:

Yeti Dk wrote:

If Onett comes back it should be redisned to be Nintens Home Town, the Melee onett isn't even politically correct in how its set up, it needs a redisngn.

Yeah, don't want to offend the Mother 2 fans

It's called EarthBound. You offend me sir.
Also, 3 stages. And to be honest, Ninten's home town of Podunk isn't a bad idea.

I think Esper meant that sarcastically.

UPDATE AS OF 5/25/12 @ 12:38AM

PLEASE READ

Well then, I guess its time to come to a close for the Mother series numbered stage poll. Confirmed number of stages for the Mother series, which has been voted by the community, will be 3 stages in total.

Since the status of Onett seems unknown and doesn't have much support after it's removal from Crusade during demo 0.8 development, Onett will not be on the confirmed list of the Mother stages. But to be fair to those who support it, I'll add it on this poll along with the other candidates.

Due to the Onett issue as well as Fourside already being playable in the current demo, 2 out 3 spots remain for the series'. Therefore you can vote up to two choices.
______________________________________________________________

Here are the rules to this poll:

1. You can only vote up to 2 Mother stages of your choice no matter what your reason is.
2. You are welcome to add new candidates to the poll if you dont see a stage that is appealing to you.
3. There is no deadline. The poll will close once the topic dies out.
4. Please don't rush the topic
5. Pre-Emptive votes will not be added.

______________________________________________________________

Total Of 0 Have Voted

Currently Winning

1st Place:

2nd Place:

Runner Up (but still losing):
_______________________________________________________________

Mother Stage Candidates

0 votes for Onett [Melee version or Revamp] (Earthbound/Mother 2, Smash Bros Melee, Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

0 votes for Magicant (Mother 1)
wiki video 1 video 2

0 votes for Moonside (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

0 votes for New Pork City [Brawl version or Revamp] (Mother 3 & Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

0 votes for Mt. Itoi [Gigyas' location] (Mother 1)
wiki video

0 votes for Cave Of The Past [Gigyas' location] (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

0 votes for Podunk (Mother 1)
wiki video

0 votes for Tazmilly Village (Mother 3)
wiki video sprites

My first vote shall go to Magicant. The other vote will be put on hold for now.

Magicant and Tazmily Village.

AH! forgot all about Tazmilly Village. Going to add that on the next update. Sorry I forgot to add it, but those of you can still vote for it and will be added on next update.

EDIT:

Added wiki, video, & sprites for Tazmilly Village on poll.

Voting for Podunk and Mt.Itoi. I really want a Mother 1 stage in this.

Tazmily Village and Magicant

Magicant and Tazmily

Voting for Mt. Itoi and Tazmilly.

Reasoning is that we should have at least one 'villain' stage for Mother, which means either Ioti, New Pork, or Cave of the Past. Since Tazmilly is going to win, I'm going with the Mother 1 option. I also don't want all 3 of our stages to be city-like, which would happen if Podunk won the Mother 1 rep.
Tazmilly only because of a Mother 3 rep...

If tazmilly is going to win, i found a 3D version of it (sort of) which could be helpful for the stage layout

Tazmilly and Magicant.

Mt. Itoi and Cave of the Past.

Mt. Itoi and a revamped New Pork.

New Pork and Magicant

My other vote shall go to Tazmilly.

My Vote : Tazmilly Village & Moonside

Keven wrote:

My Vote : Tazmilly Village & Moonside

Moonside IS Fourside. But trippy. Do not waste your second vote on a stage that is basically in game already. All you gotta do to get Moonside is change the lighting on Fourside.

UPDATE AS OF 5/26/12 @ 1:19AM

PLEASE READ

Confirmed number of stages for the Mother series, which has been voted by the community, will be 3 stages in total.

Since the status of Onett seems unknown and doesn't have much support after it's removal from Crusade during demo 0.8 development, Onett will not be on the confirmed list of the Mother stages. But to be fair to those who support it, I'll add it on this poll along with the other candidates.

Due to the Onett issue as well as Fourside already being playable in the current demo, 2 out 3 spots remain for the series'. Therefore you can vote up to two choices.
______________________________________________________________

Here are the rules to this poll:

1. You can only vote up to 2 Mother stages of your choice no matter what your reason is.
2. You are welcome to add new candidates to the poll if you dont see a stage that is appealing to you.
3. There is no deadline. The poll will close once the topic dies out.
4. Please don't rush the topic
5. Pre-Emptive votes will not be added.

______________________________________________________________

Total Of 11 Have Voted

Currently Winning

1st Place: Tazmilly Village (7 votes)

2nd Place: Magicant (6 votes)

Runner Up (but still losing): Mt. Itoi (4 votes)
_______________________________________________________________

Mother Stage Candidates

0 votes for Onett [Melee version or Revamp] (Earthbound/Mother 2, Smash Bros Melee, Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

6 votes for Magicant (Mother 1)
wiki video 1 video 2

1 votes for Moonside (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

2 votes for New Pork City [Brawl version or Revamp] (Mother 3 & Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

4 votes for Mt. Itoi [Gigyas' location] (Mother 1)
wiki video

1 votes for Cave Of The Past [Gigyas' location] (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

1 votes for Podunk (Mother 1)
wiki video

7 votes for Tazmilly Village (Mother 3)
wiki video sprites

Ok i did not know thanks Blue im changing my vote Moonside = Mt. Itoi .

Magicant and Tazmilly

Magicant and Tazmilly. I'm really just trusting that you all know way more about Mother/Earthbound than I do.

UPDATE AS OF 5/27/12 @ 12:34AM

PLEASE READ

Confirmed number of stages for the Mother series, which has been voted by the community, will be 3 stages in total.

Since the status of Onett seems unknown and doesn't have much support after it's removal from Crusade during demo 0.8 development, Onett will not be on the confirmed list of the Mother stages. But to be fair to those who support it, I'll add it on this poll along with the other candidates.

Due to the Onett issue as well as Fourside already being playable in the current demo, 2 out 3 spots remain for the series'. Therefore you can vote up to two choices.

NOTE: I'M ADDING MY VOTE HERE AND NOW. MY VOTES BEING Mt. Inoi & Tazmilly Village
______________________________________________________________

Here are the rules to this poll:

1. You can only vote up to 2 Mother stages of your choice no matter what your reason is.
2. You are welcome to add new candidates to the poll if you dont see a stage that is appealing to you.
3. There is no deadline. The poll will close once the topic dies out.
4. Please don't rush the topic
5. Pre-Emptive votes will not be added.

______________________________________________________________

Total Of 14 Have Voted

Currently Winning

1st Place: Tazmilly Village (11 votes)

2nd Place: Magicant (9 votes)

Runner Up (but still losing): Mt. Itoi (6 votes)
_______________________________________________________________

Mother Stage Candidates

0 votes for Onett [Melee version or Revamp] (Earthbound/Mother 2, Smash Bros Melee, Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

9 votes for Magicant (Mother 1)
wiki video 1 video 2

0 votes for Moonside (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

2 votes for New Pork City [Brawl version or Revamp] (Mother 3 & Smash Bros Brawl)
wiki video 1 video 2

6 votes for Mt. Itoi [Gigyas' location] (Mother 1)
wiki video

1 votes for Cave Of The Past [Gigyas' location] (Earthbound/Mother 2)
wiki video

1 votes for Podunk (Mother 1)
wiki video

11 votes for Tazmilly Village (Mother 3)
wiki video sprites

Not voting. I know nothing at all about the series

I don't think Earthbound Magicant videos are the best possible representation of Mother 1 Magicant.