Subject: Should Onett come back? Sat Apr 07, 2012 11:52 am
As we all know, Onett was removed from Crusade's 0.8 stage roster. Do you think it should come back, or are you glad that it's gone?
I myself don't really miss it, since its sprites were terrible and that it was very glitchy. Although, if these issues can be amended, then I have no problem with it returning.
Here's some gameplay of it from 0.6.
Spoiler:
Bloody Gallade Level 3 CPU
91
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat Apr 07, 2012 1:17 pm
Only if it's less ugly.
Keven Level 5 CPU
468
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat Apr 07, 2012 1:24 pm
If Onett have a Sprite Update its yes for me .
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat Apr 07, 2012 1:25 pm
No. Reason being that BluePsychic has the idea to have Magicant, which would be a MUCH better stage to rep Ness, as well as Mother 1.
Smash King Smash King
8744 EJ88201
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat Apr 07, 2012 1:46 pm
ONETT FOR 0.9.
Enough Said
Chaotic Chao Level 4 CPU
249 ChaotixChao
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 7:24 am
PLEASE bring it back! ...Wait, did you say MAGICANT!? ...*Is thinking whether or not to cancel vote now*
Maikeru Level 5 CPU
486
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 9:19 am
Yes
Dr.MarioX Level 8 CPU
1703
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 9:25 am
I think if we could render out the main parts rather than keeping a single image, it would look better. We'd also have to not pull a Phantom by not resizing it.
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 9:34 am
If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1.
So NO. Instead...Onett should be DLC. And get a resprite.
M. Bison Level 5 CPU
449
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 10:12 am
I vote No.
Equinox Level 5 CPU
379
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 10:58 am
No. Since it was removed, it would make more sense if it returned as DLC.
Perfect Hell
8837
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 12:46 pm
[quote="BluePsychic"]If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1. quote] F-zero: 2 of 3 stages are veteran stages, both from the same game out of an 8 game series. Your point is not valid
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 12:57 pm
[quote="perfecthell4"]
BluePsychic wrote:
If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1. quote] F-zero: 2 of 3 stages are veteran stages, both from the same game out of an 8 game series. Your point is not valid
No, not really. Whoever decided that Mute City MUST be the Melee version is stupid, as we already have an F-Zero Melee past stage. We should come up with our own Mute City design.
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Fri May 18, 2012 4:03 pm
Well, this topic suddenly exploded after being quiet for over a month.
Also, I'm gonna say no as well.
Chaotic Chao Level 4 CPU
249 ChaotixChao
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat May 19, 2012 8:16 am
*Changes vote to no after reading Psychic's wonderful argument*
Perfect Hell
8837
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sat May 19, 2012 7:00 pm
BluePsychic wrote:
perfecthell4 wrote:
BluePsychic wrote:
If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1.
F-zero: 2 of 3 stages are veteran stages, both from the same game out of an 8 game series. Your point is not valid
No, not really. Whoever decided that Mute City MUST be the Melee version is stupid, as we already have an F-Zero Melee past stage. We should come up with our own Mute City design.
Another point that makes no sense at all. Mute City being Melee version or ot has nothing in the slightest to do with the fact that it reps the original F-Zero
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sun May 20, 2012 8:57 am
perfecthell4 wrote:
BluePsychic wrote:
perfecthell4 wrote:
BluePsychic wrote:
If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1.
F-zero: 2 of 3 stages are veteran stages, both from the same game out of an 8 game series. Your point is not valid
No, not really. Whoever decided that Mute City MUST be the Melee version is stupid, as we already have an F-Zero Melee past stage. We should come up with our own Mute City design.
Another point that makes no sense at all. Mute City being Melee version or ot has nothing in the slightest to do with the fact that it reps the original F-Zero
Mute City should have a new design not like the Melee version. Thats all I said. It was nothing about representation.
Perfect Hell
8837
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sun May 20, 2012 9:07 am
BluePsychic wrote:
perfecthell4 wrote:
BluePsychic wrote:
perfecthell4 wrote:
BluePsychic wrote:
If Onett comes back then two of the EarthBound stages are veteran. Seeing as EarthBound will most likely have three stages, that make TWO of THREE stages veteran. Seriously? Mario only has ONE or TWO veteran stages. Also, the way I see it, it would be perfect if Onett does not return, because, we have Fourside (Past Stage, Reps Mother 2), Magicant (Reps Mother 1, and Mother 2), Mother 3 stage (Reps Mother 3). If this is how is boils down, we rep all three Mother Games, AND we have a past stage. Onett ruins this. If Onett comes back, we have not only two veteran stages, but two EarthBound stage, leaving NO room for a stage to rep Mother 1.
F-zero: 2 of 3 stages are veteran stages, both from the same game out of an 8 game series. Your point is not valid
No, not really. Whoever decided that Mute City MUST be the Melee version is stupid, as we already have an F-Zero Melee past stage. We should come up with our own Mute City design.
Another point that makes no sense at all. Mute City being Melee version or ot has nothing in the slightest to do with the fact that it reps the original F-Zero
Mute City should have a new design not like the Melee version. Thats all I said. It was nothing about representation.
Actually, you disputed my point about representation, then went on to make unrelated statements instead of backing up your view. See bolded statements Unless by saying "no, not really" you actually meant that your earlier point was in fact invalid
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sun May 20, 2012 2:37 pm
I must have said things wrong. IMO, no series should have 2/3's of their stages be past stages. We can be more original than that. If there is a way we can bring Onett back while still having two new stages, go for it. Going off of my statement in this post, Mute City should be redesigned not like the Melee version, but our own unique design.
But that is true, my argument about the past stage thing is invalid, if Mute City is to be the Melee version. (Which I feel we should avoid.)
Now that I have clarified things, I still stand by my earlier position of NO, even though it seems Onett will be back anyway.
Perfect Hell
8837
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Sun May 20, 2012 6:40 pm
Why is it only invalid if we go off the Melee version? Even if we redesign it, that doesn't change which game it most represents
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Mon May 21, 2012 11:42 am
True. I just want to avoid using multiple past stages from the same series. Thats why I want a redesign.
AEM
1763 Ariand54321
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Mon May 21, 2012 11:48 am
As much as I'd love to see Onett again. I agree with the fact that we shouldn't have more returning stages then new ones.
So I'll have to say no.
Mp3 Toaster
633 Mp3_Toaster
Subject: Re: Should Onett come back? Mon May 21, 2012 1:24 pm
I don't think Onett should return. Not only because it ruins potential representation as it has been mentioned earlier, the stage is not working well with the current engine, even when the engine has gotten revamps. Onett shouldn't return anyway, it's an ugly looking stage! And it's not that fun to fight on either.