PC Mafia - Pokemon [Mafia Victory]

Sorry about this... Vote: AEM.

Just checked... apparently I was wrong... Fenni was a cop and not a watcher.

Anyway, I've made my choice.

VOTE: SP

Read the role again. He was the cop.

blargh when pages are posted in between things

Also if you're voting me solely based on my Pokemon why would I claim a scummy Pokemon when I could literally claim whatever I wanted out of 700+ Pokemon? I'm voting to lynch Sliss based on role claims counteracting each other. If you're still going to vote me based on something trivial as my character claim when I could have easily lied about it if I was a scum you're just bringing the Town's defeat closer.

I'm still the only person really voting with explaining their reasoning, the rest of you are literally just voting and going "thats my choice". Iunno how many of you have actually mafia'd in the past but not communicating with others is how we lose and the scum wins.

I voted sp based on that the fact that nothing he did was pro-town. All his (minimal) actions consisted of blaming others and generating humorus stories to rationalise his choices.

AEM wrote:

blargh when pages are posted in between things

Also if you're voting me solely based on my Pokemon why would I claim a scummy Pokemon when I could literally claim whatever I wanted out of 700+ Pokemon? I'm voting to lynch Sliss based on role claims counteracting each other. If you're still going to vote me based on something trivial as my character claim when I could have easily lied about it if I was a scum you're just bringing the Town's defeat closer.

I'm still the only person really voting with explaining their reasoning, the rest of you are literally just voting and going "thats my choice". Iunno how many of you have actually mafia'd in the past but not communicating with others is how we lose and the scum wins.

(I've played epicmafia for 2 years, I most likely have the most mafia experience here, I would think)

You started a bandwagon of sorts, and kept trying to get Sliss voted; oddly enough, he's not even voting you, he's voting someone else entirely. It's quite foolish to vote based on character.

ALSO, when I voted you, you took off your vote for Sliss and voted me..wouldn't a hardened mafia vet know not to do that?

And another thing; you said we shouldn't vote based on Pokemon, but half of your post voting me was based on how out of place I am. Quite rude, and quite hypocritical.


So there's an explanation for my own reasoning, as I assume you'd like.

I'd rather keep an eye on you.

(by the way aem, you're a good guy in my book, don't take this personally, please; i'm just trying to defend myself, i hope this doesn't come across as hostile. all nikki supporters are family)

Alright Sliss I guess that makes sense.
Memes should die.


Shaq, if you read my post I voted you based on your role claim. Someone who openly claims Vengeful does so in order to not get lynched. I challenged your claim because a scummy who claims Vengeful does so to not get lynched. Which is why I voted you.

You claiming the only Legendary amongst us is odd too, but the majority of my reasoning was to challenge your claim.

then I later go back on sliss because of the two cop revelation thing

I initially voted Sliss because WHO CLAIMS MALAMAR. Sometimes common sense is the best sense, and Malamar with a Vengeful Cop check doesn't add up.

AEM i'm simply voting you because you started the roleclaim. This isn't an irrational line of thinking, is it?

The problem is that there seem to be a role and pokemon indentity disconnet anyway; Honchkrow doesn't seem to suit the bulletproof miller role, neither does Melloetta fit the vengeful townie role.

AEM wrote:

Alright Sliss I guess that makes sense.
Memes should die.


Shaq, if you read my post I voted you based on your role claim. Someone who openly claims Vengeful does so in order to not get lynched. I challenged your claim because a scummy who claims Vengeful does so to not get lynched. Which is why I voted you.

You claiming the only Legendary amongst us is odd too, but the majority of my reasoning was to challenge your claim.

then I later go back on sliss because of the two cop revelation thing

I initially voted Sliss because WHO CLAIMS MALAMAR. Sometimes common sense is the best sense, and Malamar with a Vengeful Cop check doesn't add up.

You vote me, but not, say, Dust, who simply said "vote me and you'll regret it"? I feel it doesn't make sense to vote me for claiming vengeful, and I did so with no vagueness.

Slissith wrote:

The problem is that there seem to be a role and pokemon indentity disconnet anyway; Honchkrow doesn't seem to suit the bulletproof miller role, neither does Melloetta fit the vengeful townie role.

I, Meloetta, love to sing.

Vengeful kills.

What kills and is a song?

Rebecca Black's Friday.

Slissith wrote:

Rebecca Black's Friday.

Memes should die

Isn't "memes should die" a meme too?

Leafyon wrote:

AEM i'm simply voting you because you started the roleclaim. This isn't an irrational line of thinking, is it?

Not necessarily. I would imagine scum would be interested in knowing who is the ideal target. Yet at the same time if nobody says anything the scum get off free. If you want a second opinion, ask Shaq I guess.

Slissith wrote:

The problem is that there seem to be a role and pokemon indentity disconnet anyway; Honchkrow doesn't seem to suit the bulletproof miller role, neither does Melloetta fit the vengeful townie role.

Miller I can see, the design for Honchkrow is inspired by your run in the mill Mob Boss. Though my move Fly allows me to dodge attacks.

If you do not mind me asking, what lets you be a Vengeful Cop in a game where a Cop and Vengeful role already exists? You're by far the biggest elephant in the room.

Lego Shaq wrote:

You vote me, but not, say, Dust, who simply said "vote me and you'll regret it"? I feel it doesn't make sense to vote me for claiming vengeful, and I did so with no vagueness.

Ugh. I'll tell you why during the night phase.

But I see where you're getting at with your role. I'll buy it. I still think Sliss is the most logical choice right now.

AEM wrote:

Leafyon wrote:

AEM i'm simply voting you because you started the roleclaim. This isn't an irrational line of thinking, is it?

Not necessarily. I would imagine scum would be interested in knowing who is the ideal target. Yet at the same time if nobody says anything the scum get off free. If you want a second opinion, ask Shaq I guess.

Slissith wrote:

The problem is that there seem to be a role and pokemon indentity disconnet anyway; Honchkrow doesn't seem to suit the bulletproof miller role, neither does Melloetta fit the vengeful townie role.

Miller I can see, the design for Honchkrow is inspired by your run in the mill Mob Boss. Though my move Fly allows me to dodge attacks.

If you do not mind me asking, what lets you be a Vengeful Cop in a game where a Cop and Vengeful role already exists? You're by far the biggest elephant in the room.

Lego Shaq wrote:

You vote me, but not, say, Dust, who simply said "vote me and you'll regret it"? I feel it doesn't make sense to vote me for claiming vengeful, and I did so with no vagueness.

Ugh. I'll tell you why during the night phase.

But I see where you're getting at with your role. I'll buy it. I still think Sliss is the most logical choice right now.

...AEM brings up valid points. I'm not taking my vote off just yet, but maybe..

AEM wrote:

Miller I can see, the design for Honchkrow is inspired by your run in the mill Mob Boss. Though my move Fly allows me to dodge attacks.

If you do not mind me asking, what lets you be a Vengeful Cop in a game where a Cop and Vengeful role already exists? You're by far the biggest elephant in the room.

Honestly I don't think so, AEM. Just because a cop and a vengeful role exists, does not a mean that an other role that incorporates aspects from both cannot exist. As you know, there are many types of Mafia games such as "non-normal" and "bastard".

Not to mention that since my ability takes place during the day, it is very difficult to role-block.

It is a very odd addition design-wise, and you have yet to answer my question regarding how your role even functions.

If you're not willing to let us in on how you do what you do, I see no reason to trust you.

None of you even know what I am
Shrouded in mystery

AEM wrote:

It is a very odd addition design-wise, and you have yet to answer my question regarding how your role even functions.

If you're not willing to let us in on how you do what you do, I see no reason to trust you.

Quite simply, when I'm Lynched or killed during the night, the alignment of a player of my choice is revealed to the public.

Dustination wrote:

None of you even know what I am
Shrouded in mystery

sucm pls

Slissith wrote:

AEM wrote:

It is a very odd addition design-wise, and you have yet to answer my question regarding how your role even functions.

If you're not willing to let us in on how you do what you do, I see no reason to trust you.

Quite simply, when I'm Lynched or killed during the night, the alignment of a player of my choice is revealed to the public.

Dustination wrote:

None of you even know what I am
Shrouded in mystery

sucm pls

If you don't understand, Sliss is Oracle.

Sliss has yet to explain how that works in the context of Malamar.

Sliss, I believe you may want to just reveal the move you have, if you wish to throw AEM off your tail.

Basically.

...Hey, wait a second, why are you pushing Sliss to reveal his role?

..Do you want to know so you'll know if he needs to be taken out quickly?

I'm pushing Sliss to explain how in the world a Malamar can act as a Vengeful Cop.

AEM wrote:

I'm pushing Sliss to explain how in the world a Malamar can act as a Vengeful Cop.

The same way a Honchkrow can be a bulletproof miller and a Melloetta a Vengeful Townie.

I suppose the justification from the fact that Malamar is Psychic pokemon that can learn Destiny Bond (albeit through bredding).

That's what I was looking for.

And I have Fly, and Shaq appears to have Perish Song.

Makes enough sense, which means I still have no reason to change my vote, unfortunately.

Well I did all I could for you town.

The only reason you're voting me from what I understand is because I'm trying to do things so rip.